For his birthday, Palmer gets an old apple core, an old sock, and a cigar butt from his new friends. What makes these gifts special? How does Palmer react to his mother's gifts?

The old used things the boys give him are proof to Palmer that they like him and want to include him in their gang. He knows the boys took time to think about what old thing to give Palmer. When Palmer's mother brings out her gifts: a soccer ball, Monopoly game, a book and a new pair of sneakers, Palmer is thankful but says to himself that the boys' presents are worth as much as hers to him.